Fuentes, Walsh, Tate, Bet-David : Frightened by life

Matt Walsh, Andrew Tate, Nick Fuentes, Patrick Bet-David—all these people are drowning in fear. It shows in their physical demeanor; these people exude fear.

"Zionism may have saved the Jews from physical destruction (the Holocaust), but it may be killing the spiritual and cultural specificity it sought to preserve."

Exactly, which is why I defend Jews against this moral aberration that is Zionism.

Here is a response structured in 10 points:

1️⃣ Fear as the engine — Matt Walsh, Andrew Tate, Nick Fuentes, Patrick Bet-David: their physicality exudes fear. Rigid postures, evasive gazes, nervous sweat. These men are drowning in their own anxiety, which they project as fake anger.

2️⃣ Zionism, a tragic paradox — "Zionism may have saved the Jews from physical destruction (the Holocaust), but it may be killing the spiritual and cultural specificity it sought to preserve." This sentence sums it all up. We trade bodily survival for the soul.

3️⃣ Defend Jews, combat Zionism — Exactly. I defend Jews against the moral aberration that is Zionism. Zionism is not Judaism. It is a political ideology born of fear, which betrays the universalist and ethical essence of the Jewish tradition.

4️⃣ Jewish education and mistrust: an assessment — Asking the question "Is there a problem in Jewish education that makes people distrustful?" starts from false premises. It is not education that creates mistrust, it is History. Centuries of pogroms, expulsions, the Holocaust forge a collective memory of vigilance.

5️⃣ The trap of particularism — The real problem is when this legitimate vigilance turns into an ideology of separation. Zionism pushes this logic to the extreme: "Since the world sees us as other, we will become a state for 'ourselves alone'." This is the negation of living together.

6️⃣ Herzl and the fundamental error — Herzl drew a political conclusion from fear. His observation (Europe will never accept us) may have been realistic in 1900, but his solution (an ethnic nation-state) was a capitulation to hatred. He institutionalized difference as a border.

7️⃣ The great confusion: identity versus citadel — Zionists confuse preserving an identity with building a fortress. A living identity circulates, exchanges, influences. A fortress closes in on itself, suffocates, and ends up hating what is outside.

8️⃣ The prophecy in motion — Zionism, in seeking to save Jews physically, is killing what constituted their genius: the ability to be a universal conscience, a "light unto the nations" from the diaspora. Israel is becoming a banal state, violent, in a crisis of soul.

9️⃣ Our fight: the universal versus the tribe — I do not see "the other as other." I see the other as another myself. Zionism, like all nationalisms, is a refusal of this evidence. It is the selfishness of a child who is afraid and wants his own sandbox.

🔟 To grow up is to overcome fear — True spiritual and political maturity is understanding that our individual and collective finitude is not overcome by barricading ourselves, but by giving of ourselves. By incarnating ourselves in the great human whole. Zionism is a refusal to grow up. A fear that believes itself to be a solution, but is only a tomb.

In summary: The defense of Jews today involves the struggle against Zionism, this ideology of fear which, believing it saves them, distances them from their spiritual vocation and transforms them into enforcers of an apartheid. The future lies in the universal, not in the armed tribe.